Exclusively on primeurs.tv : scores and reviews from Andreas Larsson and Markus Del Monego

PRIMEURS: 8 to 11 April

 

Bordeaux En Primeur:

History, samples, pros and cons, scores, prices…

 

History

 

Selling wines en primeur is a very old practice in Gironde, starting in the 18th century. From then until the mid-20th century, most of the harvest was bottled in the wine merchants’ warehouses. The wineries did not all have the technical capacity nor the necessary storage to bottle wine on their own property.
 
The practice of bottling wine in the chateau started slowly in the early 1920s. Baron Philippe de Rotschild, started this initiative by making chateau bottling mandatory for the entire harvest of Mouton Rotschild (wine). Wine bottling has been working the same way since then, the wine from the latest harvest is bottled at the chateau 18 to 24 months after its barreling, then it is sold to wine merchants.
 
In the city of Bordeaux, buying wines en primeur means that customers purchase wines from the latest harvest at an early stage: while it is still in a barrel. Only the grands crus classés and some highly rated wines can be bought en primeur, which means between 200 and 300 Châteaux (the number changes every year). The success of en primeur sales depends on the general fame of the vintage, and on the global economic conditions.
 
-     In May / April, journalists release their comments on the wine tasting, along with their grades.
 
-     From May to the end of June, prices are offered and the wines are put on sale. Initially, only traders from the Bordeaux market can buy these wine en primeur, at a lower price than after the bottling. Then these same wines will be offered to other French and international traders.
 
-     18 months later, the bottles of wine are delivered to the purchasers. The grands crus classes are then delivered a little later.
 
The Châteaux offer prices for their wines and virtually give a part of their latest harvest at reduced rate to the merchants, who then also virtually sell these same boxes of wine to other purchasers. Trust is a key factor is this process.
 
In the early 1970s, primeurs were initially only about tasting the vintages from the 200 or 300 upscale châteaux for the en primeur sales. The name “semaine des primeurs” (primeurs’ week) comes from this tasting period.
Fine wines from Pauillac, Saint-Emilion and Graves are fermented for 12 to 18 months in barrels. They are only available 24 months after the harvest. 
 
Meanwhile potential purchasers come and taste samples of these wines to make investments in particular wines.
 
Once the price has been set by the property owners, the merchants will put these wines on sale in advance in May or June. Since there is often more demand than supply, especially for fine years such as 2010, having a good producer and merchant network is essential. The average buyer is the final customer who can take advantage of this system by booking and paying in advance for the product.
 
Recently, a dozen of other tastings, not traditionally included, have been combined to this unique process. Low-end and mid-range products, federations, enologists, and clubs try to organize numerous meetings in order to take advantage of the media coverage, as they do during the Vinexpo exhibition for instance, which promotes all wines from Bordeaux

 

The early sample should not be mistaken as a Bordeaux Primeur.

 

As a reminder, here is a definition of 'Vin Primeur', which is a wine which may be sold in the same year as in which it was harvested. This kind of wine is characteristically fruity. Representative samples of the wine are initially presented to journalists, potential buyers, purchasing advisers.
 
They can taste the wine about one or two years before the wine is put on the market (place) so that buyers get an idea of the quality of the future product. It allows owners to show what will be delivered while at the same time, trying to show off the quality of their product.

 

What is a Primeur sample ?

 

Primeurs are introduced in Bordeaux on the first week of April, although winemakers start thinking about how to make it far earlier: at the beginning of the fermentation phase, or even as soon as the harvest is done.
 
The sample is first made at the property with help from advisors, crew, friends, and sometimes even the owner himself.
 
There are many ways to make a sample. Basically it is about trying different blendings and taste them, which will lead to the final version of the sample. What we are trying to do here is get a decent “wine-to-be”, which can be quite challenging since the wine is very volatile at this stage. Moreover, it may not be so appealing at such an early fermenting stage: the wine is far from being ready to drink, it is actually just starting to develop into existence.
 
Therefore you could say that tasting Primeur samples is about trying to turn a negative into an HD image. Very few tasters are able to accurately find out what the sample is going to be like, and of course people’s own subjectivity has to be taken into account.

 

How are samples made?

 

Many people wonder how exactly Primeur samples are made. There is not one unique “recipe” that works every time, man’s creativity is endless and it would take a whole book to write everything about all the methods. This is why we are not going to explain them all here, but only summarize a few of them.
 
One may select some grapes and have them fermented in a barrel so the tannin and fruit are properly assimilated. The point is to lead the wine to a convenient fermenting stage faster than usual.
 
Another possibility is to take samples from several barrels, blend them together to try and get a “tastable” sample. One can also add some wine from an elder vintage (up to 15% legally). 
 
Oenology techniques such as gum Arabic and micro-oxygenation can be used as well. 

 

Why do winemakers alter samples?

 

Some people may ask why the samples are altered so much. Can’t they be just taken directly from barrels and then tasted as they are with no modifications made? Should winemakers alter samples in order to try and make them taste as close to the final result as possible, or should they introduce them just as they are the day the tasting takes place and let tasters imagine how it will change?
 
There is controversy about altering samples because some people think that it might lead winemakers to use whatever methods in order to get high scores. 
 
You might also wonder what the point of introducing an altered sample is because 20 months later the wine will not always taste like the sample did. The alterations are meant to have the taste of the already fermented wine, while it actually is only a couple of months old.
 
On the other hand, some winemakers have a philosophical point of view on the matter: altering samples are meant to introduce the wine as they think it will be when it is ready.
 
Science and ethics both have their place in the altering process. Trying and introducing a good sample in order to promote the future wine is blameless. Trying by any means necessary to get the highest score by showing off an unrealistic sample is not reputable.
Let us remember that wine is not only about tasting : it is about drinking, sharing, experiencing sensations…

 

Pros and cons:

1: Pros

 

Château Latour’s manager has recently announced their decision to leave the Primeur system next year. Some people suggest that this could be the beginning of the end for the Bordeauxen primeur” sales. In any case it leads people to wonder whether ending the Primeur tradition would be a good or bad thing.
 
The Primeur system relies on the existence of many Bordeaux over 400 merchants.
 
By selecting a number of traders with different strengths, the Château can ensure a good overall distribution of its wines to a wide variety of merchants. The existence of these traders, managed by knowledgeable wine professionals who travel the world to promote and provide global distribution for Bordeaux wines, is a major asset for producers of Bordeaux.
The primeur system also is a good thing for wine purchasers. There are many “first class” traders and the competition between them is so intense that they are able to charge moderate prices. This enables global distribution of wines at a relatively low cost.
 
Once a wine’s price has been fixed, the price is announced to the merchants by the brokers. This can happen, for example, around 11:30 in the morning: if all goes well, all the merchants have made confirmations of their reservations a couple of hours later.
 
Then it is the merchant’s turn to offer wine they have purchased to their partners around the world, who then purchase the wine.
 
In a good year, this whole selling process can be completed within hours, by the end of the day the properties have sold all their vintages (or the amount they have decided to put on the market), which means they able to virtually distribute their wines globally within hours. The wineries have the clear advantage in this system.
 
From the perspective of the purchasers, buying wine en primeur is a very effective way to acquire wine from vineyards across the world. If the property tried to distribute the wine themselves, without working within the trading network, it would be more costly and less effective, because it would be impossible to ensure the remarkable worldwide distribution that traders are capable of achieving.

 

2 : Cons

 

There are striking examples of spectacular improvements in the “primeurs” samples.
 
The chateau selects about twenty of the best tasting barrels and performs blending to produce the best primeur samples possible.
 
Some vineyards even place these selected barrels in heated cellars to accelerate the malolactic fermentation, so that the samples are more attractive by March.
 
We do realize that a strategy is initiated; select the best wine, and "work" on it so that it presents best during primeur wine tastings. This is crucial, as it will decide the commercial success of the vintage.
 
Some even speak of samples developed specifically for professional tasters...
It is therefore understandable why the final bottled result can sometimes slightly differ from primeur samples. Knowing this, amateurs should avoid buying en primeur out of elementray caution because it will not give them advantages.
 
He purchases, two years before being on the market, a wine that he has most likely not been tasted, based on marks given by pros who tasted the samples they were given, and whose resemblance to the final product is at least questionable.
 
The problem is the Bordeaux wine vending machine is so well oiled, it manages to make customers believe that if they don’t buy en primeur, they no longer have access to the most sought-after wines, at least not to the "friendly prices" made during primeur campaigns.
 
This process seems contrary to common sense, as most people notice that almost all wines (except perhaps a dozen labels) are available for many years at similar or even lower prices than en primeur.
 
And yet, it works and it will continue to work for a while, considering the excitement and pressure that the Primeur forum in May and June brings every year...
 
One may consider that the people responsible for this absurd system, pushing to haste and greed, are: vineyards, journalists and ...................... amateurs!
 
This controversy reflects some of today's prominent societal issues.

 

Scores

 

Scores are determinant for business purposes: they enable producers to decide on skyrocketed prices for private sales which start immediately after. This private sales system which is unique to Bordeaux allow wine producers to sell their product twenty months before the delivery time.
 
At the time of purchase, the buyers can only rely on evaluations made by wine critics who, compared to the former, have had the privilege to taste the wines. While this practice is a boon to wine producers to whom it is highly profitable, to others it is equivalent to a curse when a vintage is poorly rated and the demand for the wine declines. In such a situation, the châteaux can either lower their prices or decide not to adopt the private sales system, hoping for an increase in their price level after some months. This last option has been adopted by the Château Latour who, on the 16th of April 2013, made an announcement on its withdrawal from the private sales market. "Our wine will be available on the market at the time they are ready for consumption", said the director of Château Latour to the traders.

 

Prices

 

As with the stock market or real estate in major cities, you can not win every year. But over time, buying fine wines en primeur is a good deal. It is a safe investment since you cannot lose any money ; your investment can only grow in value. The primeur market deals with 200-300 upscale chateaux, selected according to their excellent reputations. These wines are very popular all over the world. However the amount of bottles produced is limited because the properties’ surfaces cannot be indefinitely extended.
 
Of course, for the « elite of the elite », there’s always a high demand.
 
Ausone 2008 (Saint-Emilion), released at 480 euros, is now valued  at 1 500 euros! Château Margaux went from 178 to 780 euros; Latour (Pauillac) went from 168 to 1230 euros; Petrus (Pomerol) went from 295 to 2400 euros.
 
The biggest price increase was for Carruades, - second wine from Chateau Lafite (Pauillac) and an icon in China, whose price has increased tenfold in two years (from 54.50 to 530 euros).
/ EN PRIMEURS 2012
Michel Rolland, The Flying Winemaker Tells us about his experience with the Primeurs
Markus Del Monego tells us about En Primeurs tasting
Markus Del Monego tells us about Margaux, Pauillac and Saint Julien
Markus Del Monego tells us about Sauternes and Barsac
Markus Del Monego tells us about Haut-Medoc Moulis and Listrac
Cyril Mondon from Socamil Leclerc tells us about Primeurs
Andreas Larsson tells us about Saint Estephe
Andreas Larsson tells us about Right bank, Saint-Emilion and Pomerol
Andreas Larsson tells us about Pessac Leognan
Andreas Larsson tells us about En Primeurs tasting
Markus Del Monego gives details about the 2012 vintage for Chinese amateurs, and offers some tasting advice.
Andreas Larsson highlights the extraordinary variety of valur for money wines that Bordeaux offers.
Chinese amateurs will be interested in Fronsac, Bordeaux and Bordeaux Supérieur, Graves, Francs, Blaye etc...
Primeurs, it works
10th April
We met Michel Rolland last night at the Rolland Collection Party, and he shares his thoughts.

Primeurs are fabulous but we can say that it is a nightmare at the same time, because each of the wines has to be presented at its best condition! So we can call it “delicate”.
Wine market goes beyond comments during the Primeurs. We’d never seen one of the Premier Grand Crus Classés loses the market or reduces the price, since he got a bad note.

In order to do the best for the Primeurs, it calls for “experience”. It’s a real job, complicated and delicate.

There is only one taster who tastes perfectly the Primeurs, because he makes fewer mistakes and has a great experience, thus he influences the wine market more than anyone else.

Even after 40 years of his experiences, Michel Rolland still has doubts about the Primeurs.
Pichon Comtesse Longueville
2ème Grand Cru Classé, Pauillac
Very nice to see that they really started from square one as the quality has not be top in the last years; 2012 was very convincing, and the new team really know what they are doing.
Chateau Ducru-Beaucaillou
2ème Grand Cru Classé, Saint Julien
Simply amazing, with a great quality of Cabernet Sauvignon, the power and concentration yet with a soft and delicate extraction, was truly a thrilling wine.
Chateau Cos D'Estournel
2ème Grand Cru Classé, Saint Estephe
Was really nice, those wines have been changing quiet a lot, and they're marked by the beautiful richness and fruit; but yet with a softer extraction and more delicate oak treatment.
Chateau Tertre Roteboeuf
Grand Cru, Saint Emilion
A great discovery it’s one of the best wine of this vintage, very sensual discovery; it’s a wine which display pure emotion. It's definitely worth to be discovered.
Chateau Pavie-Macquin
1er Grand Cru Classé B, Saint Emilion
Exceptional in its purity definition of fruit, good level of extraction, with a soft very long fresh finish.
Chateau Puygueraud: a great result for this vintage; it’s the leader of Franc Cote de Bordeaux, best young exemple we have tried of that wine.
Clos Fourtet
1er Grand Cru Classé B, Saint Emilion
Beautiful, sensual, soft texture, rather Burgundian, supple with great length.
Saint Emilion
Has an amazing diversity; the wines have a common thread but yet they’re showing a lot of different characters.
Jean-Pierre Moueix
A great and pure Trotanoy, one of the best wines in this vintage.
Wonderful Chateau La Fleur Petrus, as a lot of other great wines, shows the diversity of terroir and portfolio of Moueix managed on a very high quality level.
The special “coup de coeur” for Andreas, was neither as famous as Trotanoy, or La Fleur Petrus, it was La Providence, such a beautiful silkily sexy pomerol, truly astonishing, it’s our honor.
Chateau L'Evangile
Pomerol
A great definition of purity class and elegance and also results of success of Pomerol.
Chateau Angelus
1er Grand Cru Classé A, Saint Emilion
Pretty amazing,it spreads its richness and concentration, it really shows great elegance vibrancy and freshness, it truly belongs to the top league.
Right bank - Left bank
Right bank is normally easier as you get the ripeness, the roundness more easli, had bit more charm. In the left bank, for the great terroir they could make some good wines but they really need the struggle, in order to get ripeness not to getting great tannins and austerity.
Chateau Beauséjour Bécot
1er Grand Cru Classé B, Saint Emilion
A lot of wine : The taste shows the great diversity you find in the right bank in Bordeaux.
CHATEAU PAVIE
1er grand cru classé A, Saint-Emilion
Proves again to be a safe value in 2012,very well late wine with an expressive character and all the other wines have been from seducing till great tasting experience.
Chateau Ausone
1er Grand Cru Classé A, Saint Emilion
Wahoo. It’s something special. There are few great wines that you put your nose in and you say: « oh my God!! »
Chateau Cheval Blanc
1er grand cru classé A, Saint-Emilion
One of the freshness, typical influence of Cabernet Franc, which shows again that red wine needs great terroir in 2012.
Chateau Pétrus
Pomerol
Was impressing due to its incredible power, yes its incredible softness and sillkness, very sexy and lushly wine.
Chateau Léoville Poyferré
2ème Grand Cru Classé, Saint Julien
Highly impressed, not only by Léoville Poyferré but really by Moulin Riche; a lot of people thinks that it’s a second wine, at the matter fact it is not a second wine, it is an other terroir; it really improved, it has reach the state of a second/third growth, it is an amazing wine.
Léoville Poyferré it’s not a surprise, it’s just one of the best wines of Bordeaux; and when you taste a wine like that, the limit between a First or a second Growth it’s really nearly there anymore. Léoville Poyferré has confirmed his place among all the leading Wineries/Chateaux in the Bordeaux area.
Chateau Latour
1er Grand Cru Classé, Pauillac
An exciting tasting experience, in the true tradition of the terroir of the Chateau Latour.
Chateau Margaux
1er Grand Cru Classé, Margaux
Great pure Cabernet Sauvignon, and the touch of elegance.
It is the vintage of really great terroirs. In the vintage, only the great terroirs have the capacity to produce truly great wine.
Chateau Palmer
3ème Grand Cru Classé, Margaux
Chateau Pontet Canet
5ème Grand Cru Classé, Pauillac
As usual, rich flamboyant, concentrated style
Chateau Mouton Rothschild
1er Grand Cru Classé, Medoc
Opulent, a wonderful of richness and purity for the Cabernet Sauvignon.
Chateau Lafite Rothschild
1er grand cru classé, Pauillac
As usual, a quiet restrained fruit and elegant style
Joanne
The tasting at Joanne was incredible because we had 150 wines to taste and had a perfect all view over different appellations in Bordeaux. So withing the next days you will have alle the different tasting results, with some very good surprises and some real,as the French say, "coup de coeur".
Google+